Almost every week a company forwards us the same email: "Amazon has invited us to Vendor Central, shall we accept?". Put like that, it sounds like a promotion. Selling directly to Amazon, appearing as "sold and shipped by Amazon", no longer thinking about prices and shipping. Sometimes it really is the right choice. Often it is not, or not on its own.
Before replying to that email, it is worth understanding clearly what changes between the two models.
Two models, two different roles
With Seller Central you are a third-party seller: you list your products on the marketplace, set the price, choose whether to ship yourself (FBM) or use Amazon's logistics (FBA), and get paid by the end customer net of fees. On Amazon.it the Professional plan has a monthly fee of 39 euros plus VAT, on top of which come referral fees on individual sales.
With Vendor Central you become a supplier to Amazon. Amazon sends you purchase orders (POs), buys the goods at a wholesale price and then resells them itself. Access is by invitation only: it is not an account you can open on your own.
The real difference is not technical. In the first case you are the shopkeeper. In the second you are the wholesaler, and the shopkeeper is Amazon.
What you gain with Vendor
- Volumes that are simpler to manage: one wholesale order instead of thousands of individual sales.
- Customer trust: the product shows as sold and shipped by Amazon, which matters a lot in some categories.
- Less day-to-day operational work on price and customer service, which pass to Amazon.
For a company used to working with large retailers, the Vendor model feels familiar: price list, orders, deliveries, invoices.
What you lose, and usually nobody tells you
Control over the retail price is the first thing. Amazon decides what to sell at and can lower the price to match other channels. If you have resellers or your own eCommerce site, this can create tensions on your price list that show later, not straight away.
Then there are the commercial terms, renegotiated periodically. Industry guides cite payment terms of 30, 60 or 90 days and a series of contributions borne by the supplier: marketing allowances (often quoted at around 5-10% of sales), damage allowances, freight contributions. Each item on its own seems small. Added together, they change the margin significantly.
Finally, predictability: Amazon decides the orders. They can be large, shrink or stop, and production planning has to take that into account.
When Seller makes sense
In most of the cases we see, for an Italian brand that is starting out or growing, the Seller model is the most sensible point of entry. In particular when:
- the retail price is part of the brand's positioning;
- the company also sells on other channels and must keep its price list consistent;
- you want to read sales, advertising and search data unfiltered;
- there is an expansion plan across several European countries to be managed first-hand.
The price to pay is the operational work: prices, stock, campaigns, account health. Which can, however, be organised, with the right people or the right tools.
The hybrid model
You do not have to choose just one. Several brands work in hybrid mode: some lines in Vendor, typically high-volume, low-margin products where turnover counts, and the rest in Seller, where price control and flexibility are needed.
It works if there is a clear rule on which product goes where. Without that rule you end up with the same item on two channels competing with each other, and with Amazon lowering the price exactly where the brand wanted to defend it.
How to decide, in practice
When a client brings us a Vendor invitation, before replying we do four things:
- Profit and loss per product: margin in Seller (fees, FBA, advertising) against margin in Vendor (purchase price minus all allowances).
- Cash impact: how much the payment terms weigh compared with the faster payouts of the marketplace.
- Channel check: what happens to resellers and the website if Amazon lowers the price.
- Internal capacity: who manages the account every day, if you stay in Seller.
It is the same approach as our 90-day plan: numbers first, then the choice. An invitation to Vendor Central does not expire in an afternoon. It is worth taking a week to do the sums, product by product, before signing terms that are then hard to renegotiate.
Further reading: Amazon account management · How much you really earn on Amazon
Originally published on LinkedIn

Co-founder of BusinessLabs since 2023, he leads the marketplace area: strategy, launch and growth of Amazon accounts and expansion into foreign markets, from Europe to the Emirates and South America.
LinkedIn


