eCommerce

    Amazon reviews: how to get them without putting your account at risk

    Marco Calabrese · October 1, 2026 · 4 min
    Graphic cover: Amazon reviews: how to get them without putting your account at risk

    A new product on Amazon with zero reviews starts uphill even when it is better than the competition. Customers look at the stars before they even look at the price. That is why the temptation to "help" the first reviews is strong, and that is exactly where many accounts get into trouble. Clean routes exist; they are slower, but they hold up over time.

    Why shortcuts cost dearly

    Amazon prohibits any form of review manipulation: products given away or refunded in exchange for a rating, conditional discounts, reviews from friends, relatives or employees, requests sent only to satisfied customers. The consequences range from review removal to account suspension, which is the most serious damage a seller can suffer.

    Then there is the legal side. With the Omnibus Directive, transposed in Italy into the Consumer Code, publishing or commissioning fake reviews is an unfair commercial practice, and those who also sell on their own site must state whether and how they check that reviews come from real customers. It is no longer just a matter of platform policy.

    The "Request a Review" button

    The first tool is also the most underrated. In Seller Central, in the details of each order, there is the "Request a Review" button. It can be used between 5 and 30 days after delivery, once per order, and sends the customer a standard Amazon message asking for both a product rating and a seller rating.

    The advantage is that the text is Amazon's, so it is compliant by definition. With high volumes, clicking it by hand is unthinkable, but the same request can be automated via API with authorised tools. The practical advice is not to send it on the first possible day: for a product that needs assembling or trying out, waiting a few more days gives the customer time to really use it.

    Amazon Vine: how it works and when it is worth it

    Vine is the programme through which Amazon sends the product free of charge to selected reviewers, the Vine Voices, who publish an honest opinion marked as a Vine review. The main requirements:

    • brand enrolled in Brand Registry;
    • ASIN with fewer than 30 published reviews;
    • new product, sold with Fulfilment by Amazon and with stock available;
    • up to 30 units can be enrolled per parent ASIN.

    The cost depends on the number of units enrolled and should be checked in Seller Central for the marketplace you work in, because the fee structure has changed several times in recent years. On top of this come the value of the goods given away and the FBA fees.

    Two things need to be taken into account. First: the reviewer is free, and if the product has a defect they will write about it. Vine is not a tool to inflate your average; it is a field test. Second: not all units shipped turn into reviews. It is worth enrolling a product in Vine only when the listing is already complete and the product is ready to be judged.

    The listing and the experience matter more than the requests

    The most frequent negative reviews we see are not about quality but about disappointed expectations: sizes different from what was imagined, a colour that looked different in the photo, unclear instructions. Most of these problems can be solved before the sale:

    • photos and copy that show the product as it is, including dimensions and box contents;
    • readable instructions and, if needed, an insert in the packaging with a customer-service contact (without any reference to reviews);
    • quick replies to customer messages, before the problem becomes a one-star rating.

    Reading reviews like a report

    Reviews are also data. When three different customers report the same problem, it is time to talk to the supplier or correct the listing. At BusinessLabs we read them together with returns and Account Health metrics: the listing team, with Andrea, updates the content, and the project lead reports recurring defects to the manufacturer. Our Selleee software, with the Selly Health agent, helps us keep an eye on account signals without waiting for them to become a warning.

    Where to start

    If you are launching a product, the order we suggest is simple: a complete and honest listing, Brand Registry active, Vine on the first units if the product is ready, then "Request a Review" systematically on every order. None of these moves produces a hundred reviews in a week. All together they build a reputation that nobody can take away from you with an account review.

    Further reading: Amazon account management · Brand Registry on Amazon

    Originally published on LinkedIn

    AmazonReviewsVine
    Marco Calabrese
    Author
    Marco Calabrese
    Co-Founder & Marketplace Expert

    Co-founder of BusinessLabs since 2023, he leads the marketplace area: strategy, launch and growth of Amazon accounts and expansion into foreign markets, from Europe to the Emirates and South America.

    LinkedIn

    Talk to our Amazon agency

    Book a free consultation