A multichannel pricing strategy only holds if it starts from the margin of each channel and not from the competitor's price. Anyone selling on their own website, on one or more marketplaces and perhaps in a store too usually has a single price list and applies it everywhere, with a few manual tweaks when a channel slows down. That works as long as there are two channels and few products. Then come the promotions, the repricers, the comparison sites, the colleagues who lower a price "just for this week", and the price list becomes a pile of exceptions that nobody governs. I believe the problem is rarely the level of prices. The problem is the lack of rules saying who can change them, when, and how far.
The same price on every channel does not mean the same margin
The first trap is confusing price parity with parity of results. Every channel has a different cost structure. On your own website you pay for payment processing, shipping and above all customer acquisition, meaning advertising and promotions to bring in traffic. On a marketplace you pay the sales commission, logistics and, almost always, internal advertising to stay visible. These are different items, they weigh differently from product to product, and the same selling price turns them into margins that are far apart.
Here is an example with made-up numbers, just to make the point. A product costs 20 euros to buy and sells for 50 euros. On the website, after payment, shipping and customer acquisition, 16.50 euros of margin is left. On the marketplace, after a 15% commission, logistics and advertising, 14.50 is left. So far the difference is acceptable. But if the price drops to 45 euros to win the featured offer, the commission falls a little and the margin drops to just over 10 euros, about 60% of the website's. Sales on the marketplace look good, volumes rise, and meanwhile every order earns almost a third less than before, without anyone really having decided it.
That is why the starting point is not a comparison with other people's prices. It is a table, product by product and channel by channel, showing how much is left in your pocket at every possible price. Without that table, any discussion about the right price is a discussion of opinions.
Price floor first, list price second

The second step is to calculate a price floor for every product and every channel. It is the price below which that channel stops giving you the margin you decided you want, taking into account all the costs of that channel and not only the cost of the product. The price floor is not an opinion and it is not negotiated in a meeting: it is calculated, written down and updated when commissions, shipping costs or purchase costs change.
The list price comes after and is a commercial choice. It says where you want to position yourself, what the customer is willing to pay, how much margin you want to leave for promotions. It can be the same on every channel or not, and both are fine, as long as the list price of each channel always stays above its floor with a reasonable room to move. When the two things are separate, the discussion changes nature. You no longer ask "can we go lower?" but "how much room is there between today's price and this channel's floor?". The second question has a numerical answer.
The rules that say who changes prices

A pricing policy that holds is, in the end, a small rulebook. It says who is responsible for prices, and it has to be one person, not a committee. It says which tools can change them on their own, for example a repricer on a marketplace, and within which limits: the floor, the ceiling, how often prices can change, which competitors to follow and which to ignore. It says what happens when someone wants to make an exception, who they ask and where it is recorded.
This matters even more today, when many automatic tools touch prices at night, with nobody watching. A repricer without a well-set floor is a very efficient way to sell too cheap. An AI agent trusted with the price list without clear boundaries is the same thing, only faster. The tool is not the risk. The risk is that the limit exists in somebody's head and not in the system.
It often happens that companies pass pricing rules along by word of mouth, like an oral tradition: "we never go below a certain value on that marketplace", "the website is always a bit cheaper". It works as long as the person who remembers them is in the office. Written on one page, with the numbers next to them, they become a policy. You do not need ten pages. One is enough, and anyone in the company should be able to read it in two minutes.
Price parity is a choice, not an obligation
Many business owners think they have to keep the same price everywhere, out of fear of retaliation or of confusing customers. In reality there are at least three roads. You can keep a uniform price across all channels, which is simple to communicate but leaves different margins. You can adopt a hybrid model, with the same price for the flagship products and different prices for the rest of the catalogue. Or you can build a specific price for each channel, one that reflects its costs and its audience, but demands more discipline.
None of the three is right in absolute terms. The choice depends on how much customers compare prices across channels, how recognisable your brand is and how heavily commissions weigh on your margin. What matters is that the choice is made on purpose and written down, and is not the result of a thousand tweaks piled up over time. If you decide to differentiate, you need to know why and be able to explain it to the people who work with you.
Discounts have a thirty-day memory
Then there is a topic that becomes urgent around Black Friday. In Europe, when you announce a price reduction to consumers, the reference price you calculate the discount from is the lowest price you applied in the previous thirty days. The Court of Justice of the European Union confirmed this in a ruling of 26 September 2024: it is not enough to state the previous price, the percentage has to be calculated from the lowest price of the last thirty days. In practice, if you raise the price for a few days and then lower it again while declaring a discount, that reduction does not hold up.
For anyone selling on several channels this means that price history matters, channel by channel. A price changed by hand on a Tuesday evening, or a repricer that dips for a few hours, leaves a trace that becomes your reference price for the following month. Anyone without an orderly price history discovers the problem at the worst possible moment, which is when they are preparing a promotion.
How to tell whether the policy is holding
A pricing policy is checked with a few numbers, looked at regularly, for example once a month. The first is the realised margin by channel compared with the planned one: if the gap grows, something is eroding the margin without anyone having decided it. The second is the share of sales made below the price floor, which should be zero, and every time it is not you need to find out who or what allowed that price. The third is the number of recorded exceptions: if there are many, either the floor is wrong or the rule is unclear. The fourth is how often a channel wins its best position, for example the featured offer on a marketplace, and at what price it wins it, because a position won by underselling is not a result.
These numbers are not there to police people. They are there to decide better. When a channel's margin falls and the policy is written down, the question becomes which rule needs to change. When there is no policy, the question becomes who made the mistake, and that is usually the worst question to ask.
My position
I prefer a sheet with three clear rules to a sophisticated pricing system that nobody understands. A price floor per channel calculated on real costs, a single person in charge of prices, every exception recorded: with those three things you can get through even a season full of promotions. Without them, not even the best tool prevents underselling. The right price is not the lowest one the market tolerates, nor the highest one the customer accepts. It is the one you can defend, with the numbers in hand, on every channel you sell on.

CEO & Co-Founder of BusinessLabs. I have attended major international trade shows since 2015 and share here experiences and insights for online sellers.
LinkedIn


