When a client tells us that sales of a product have collapsed overnight without anything changing, the first thing we check is who holds the featured offer, the one everyone still calls the Buy Box. On an ASIN with several sellers, the "Add to Basket" button goes to one offer only. If it is not yours, the listing can be perfect and the advertising well managed, but the revenue goes to someone else.
What changed in 2026
In July Amazon announced that it will remove the seller eligibility step for the featured offer, with a gradual roll-out to all marketplaces by the end of 2026. Until recently a seller with weak metrics was excluded from the start. With the new system all offers enter the ranking from the outset, and the criteria that decide who wins remain the usual ones: competitive price, speed and reliability of delivery, seller performance.
In practice this means one thing: competition increases on shared ASINs. Those who were previously out of the game can now enter, and those who won for lack of rivals have to earn their place.
Price matters, but it is not the only factor
The most common mistake is thinking that the featured offer always goes to the lowest price. It does not. Amazon considers the total price for the customer, shipping included, together with delivery speed and service quality. An FBA offer with Prime delivery can beat an FBM offer that costs a few cents less but arrives in four days.
That is why, before touching the price, we always look at three things:
- Availability: an offer without stock does not win, and low stock across the FBA network can also weigh.
- Delivery: realistic handling times and delivery promises, consistently met.
- Account health: order defect rate, cancellations and late shipments remain part of the calculation.
The "too high" price that makes the offer disappear
There is also the opposite problem. Under its fair pricing policy, Amazon can remove the featured offer from a product if the price is much higher than the one charged recently, on Amazon or elsewhere. It often happens after a hasty price rise or a price-list error. In the Pricing Health section of Seller Central you will find the offers that have lost eligibility and the reference price indicated by Amazon: it is the first place to check when the Buy Box disappears for all sellers.
Repricing: automatic, yes, but within limits
Following prices by hand across dozens of ASINs is not sustainable. Amazon provides the Automate Pricing tool free of charge, which adjusts prices according to rules you set, linked for example to the featured offer or the lowest price. There are also external software tools with more advanced logic.
The tool matters less than the rules. The ones we always set:
- Minimum price calculated on margin, not on gut feeling. It must cover product cost, fees, FBA charges and advertising. Below that threshold, selling makes no sense.
- Maximum price consistent with history, so as not to fall foul of the fair pricing policy.
- No race to the bottom: if two repricers chase each other one cent at a time, after a week both are selling at a loss.
- Periodic review: fees and logistics costs change, and a minimum that was right in January may no longer be right in October.
If you are the brand owner
For those selling their own brand, the Buy Box is also a question of control. Unauthorised resellers who join your listing with lower prices erode the margin and confuse the customer. Repricing is of little use here: you need a clear distribution policy, control over the channels the goods come from and, where the conditions are met, the brand protection tools Amazon provides.
Where to start
My advice is simple: take your 20 main ASINs and, for each one, check the featured offer percentage in the Seller Central reports. Where it is low, first ask yourself whether the problem is stock, delivery or the account, and only then whether it is price. Then set minimums and maximums on every product and let the repricer work within those boundaries.
At BusinessLabs we do this every day for our clients, with a single point of contact per project and the support of Selleee, our software with AI agents dedicated to account health, stock and advertising. Selly Price, the agent dedicated to pricing, is on its way. If you want to understand how much revenue you are leaving to other sellers on your listings, write to me.
Further reading: Amazon account management · Five checks every morning on your Amazon account
Originally published on LinkedIn

Co-founder of BusinessLabs since 2023, he leads the marketplace area: strategy, launch and growth of Amazon accounts and expansion into foreign markets, from Europe to the Emirates and South America.
LinkedIn


